What Hurts A Home Appraisal? 8 Factors You Can (And Can’t) Control

A miniature home with house keys.

When selling your home, a smooth appraisal process is key to finalizing the deal. The appraisal serves as an objective evaluation of your property’s market value, often determining whether a buyer’s mortgage gets approved. While some factors impacting a home appraisal are beyond your control, others can be managed to present your property in the best possible light. Understanding these factors can help you take the right steps to protect your home’s value and ensure a successful sale. Let’s explore what can hurt a home appraisal and what you can do about it.

A hand holding a miniature house.

Concerned About a Low Home Appraisal? Here’s What You Need to Know

A home appraisal is one of the final steps in the selling process, providing a professional estimate of your property’s market value. Typically requested by the buyer’s mortgage lender and paid for by the buyer, the appraisal is crucial as it confirms that the property is worth the offered price, safeguarding both the buyer and the lender. However, many sellers worry about what might negatively impact a home appraisal and the overall sale.

The appraisal’s outcome plays a vital role in your buyer’s ability to secure a mortgage. If the appraisal comes in lower than the offer price, the lender is unlikely to approve the loan, which could put your sale at risk or force you into negotiations. Ensuring the appraisal goes well is essential for a smooth transaction.

Given the significance of the appraisal, it’s wise to take proactive measures to maximize your home’s value. This includes understanding which elements can adversely affect the appraisal and which aspects are within your control to improve. By knowing what factors impact the appraisal, you can better prepare and present your home in its best light, boosting your chances of a favorable valuation.

A family visiting the home they are aiming to buy.

Why Is The Home Appraisal So Crucial?

The lender’s top priority is safeguarding their financial investment, which is why an accurate home appraisal is essential. The home serves as the buyer’s collateral for the loan, meaning the lender needs to ensure it holds sufficient value. If the buyer defaults on payments, the lender will foreclose on the home and eventually attempt to sell it. Therefore, the home must be worth at least the loan amount for the lender to mitigate their risk and avoid potential financial losses. If the appraisal falls short of the loan value, the lender may deny the loan, leaving the buyer in a difficult position.

In cases where the appraisal is lower than the offer amount, it’s highly likely that the lender will reject the loan application. Additionally, if the buyer has included a home appraisal contingency in the contract — which is a common safety measure — they will have the legal right to withdraw from the agreement without financial penalties. This protection ensures that buyers won’t be stuck overpaying for a property that doesn’t appraise at the expected value.

A couple reading the home appraisal report.

What You Can Control: How to Avoid Hurting Your Home’s Appraisal Value

Understanding what negatively impacts a home appraisal is crucial for homeowners looking to maximize their property’s value. Fortunately, many of these factors are within your control, allowing you to take proactive steps to improve your home’s appraisal. Below are some of the key elements that can lower your home appraisal and what you can do to address them effectively.

Recent Home Improvements

Any recent upgrades or renovations you’ve made to your home or property can positively impact the appraisal amount, often boosting it more than you might expect. To ensure these improvements are fully recognized, have all relevant receipts, permits, and documentation ready to present to the appraiser during their visit.

However, it’s essential to understand that not all home improvements will provide a dollar-for-dollar return on your investment. For example, while you may have spent $35,000 on a kitchen remodel, it’s unlikely the appraiser will increase your home’s value by the same amount. Being aware of this can help manage expectations and provide a realistic perspective on how improvements affect overall value.

Home and Appliance Condition

If your home is already under contract before the appraisal, it’s usually not advisable to invest additional money into replacing appliances or major systems like HVAC, plumbing, or electrical. These high-cost items are best addressed before listing your property to maximize its appeal and value during showings and negotiations.

However, ensuring that everything is in good working order and spotlessly clean can still have a positive impact. Take the time to perform a deep clean: scrub the insides of your appliances, meticulously clean grout lines, sweep, mop, and dust all surfaces. Even minor improvements, such as cleaning and organizing, can present your home in the best light, giving appraisers the impression of a well-maintained property.

Maintenance

One of the key factors that can negatively impact a home appraisal is inadequate maintenance. Regular and seasonal upkeep is crucial to keeping your house in top condition and preventing costly repairs down the line. Neglecting basic maintenance tasks, like fixing a leaky faucet or replacing worn-out weather seals, can accumulate into bigger issues that not only affect your home’s functionality but also its value. An appraiser is trained to spot these overlooked details, and any signs of neglect can lead to a lower appraisal value.

To make a positive impression during your appraisal, ensure all minor maintenance tasks are addressed beforehand. Simple actions like re-caulking tubs and showers or weatherproofing windows and doors can significantly enhance your home’s overall appearance and perceived value. Taking these proactive steps shows that you are committed to maintaining your property, which can positively influence the appraiser’s assessment.

Curb Appeal

The appraisal process starts the moment the appraiser steps onto your property, often observing details before even reaching your front door. First impressions matter, and boosting your curb appeal is crucial to creating a positive impact. Ensure your property is in its best shape to set the right tone from the beginning.

If your home has been on the market, you’ve likely already addressed major curb appeal aspects like painting the front door, updating the landscaping, and more. However, it’s essential to double-check these efforts before the appraisal to ensure they still look fresh and inviting. Take a quick tour around your property to pull weeds, rake any fallen leaves, and trim dead branches. Keep the lawn neatly mowed and well-maintained, as even the smallest details can influence the appraiser’s perception of your home.

Can a Messy Home Affect the Appraisal Outcome?

Generally, a messy house does not affect the outcome of an appraisal. Appraisers are trained professionals who focus on the home’s structural condition, location, size, and overall features that impact its market value. While clutter and disorganization may create an unappealing visual impression, they do not influence the appraiser’s assessment of the property’s value. Instead, appraisers concentrate on significant aspects like the quality of construction, the state of major systems, and any recent renovations or damages, ensuring that the final valuation is based solely on objective property characteristics rather than temporary untidiness.

Do Appraisers Look Inside Cabinets?

While home appraisers don’t typically need to look inside cabinets during their evaluations, they might do so in certain situations. Appraisers generally focus on assessing the overall condition and features of the home rather than inspecting every cabinet. However, if they notice visible damage, such as broken doors, loose hinges, or clear signs of pests, they may take a closer look to ensure these issues don’t affect the property’s value. This inspection helps them accurately report any problems that could impact the home’s marketability or safety, ultimately influencing the appraisal results.

A couple reading the home appraisal report.

Factors Beyond Your Control: How They Affect Your Home’s Appraisal

When considering what negatively impacts a home appraisal, it’s important to recognize that certain factors are simply beyond your control. While these elements are unchangeable, understanding how they influence your property’s value can help you manage expectations and plan accordingly. Awareness of these uncontrollable factors empowers homeowners to focus on areas they can improve, ensuring they are well-prepared for the appraisal process.

Local Market Trends

One of the most critical factors that can negatively affect your home appraisal, and one that’s beyond your control, is the local market. Appraisers closely examine the market trends to help determine the value of your property. Specifically, they use factors like supply and demand to predict whether the price of your home is likely to rise or fall. This makes the local real estate climate a significant element in the appraisal process.

If your home is located in an area where property values are declining, this can result in a lower appraisal. On the other hand, if you’re in a high-demand neighborhood with rising property prices, your appraisal is likely to reflect a higher value. However, even in a strong market, other factors like recent home sales and economic shifts can still influence the final outcome. Understanding this market dynamic is essential when anticipating your home’s appraisal value.

Home’s Age

Another factor beyond your control in a home appraisal is the age of your property. Typically, older homes are assigned a lower appraised value due to potential structural wear and outdated building materials. Newer homes, especially those constructed in the last 10-20 years, often comply with modern building codes, making them less likely to have significant issues. As a result, these homes generally receive a higher appraisal value compared to their older counterparts.

That said, if your home is located within a historic district, its age could work in your favor. In such areas, the historic significance of a property can actually increase its appraised value, as buyers may place a premium on its unique architectural features and cultural importance.

Home Size

When determining a home’s value, the appraiser closely examines its size along with the size of the property it sits on. Typically, larger homes tend to have a higher value, as size often correlates with increased market appeal. However, there are exceptions. A house that’s “overbuilt” — meaning it occupies too much of the property and leaves minimal outdoor space — may negatively impact the home’s value. Most homeowners prefer a balanced ratio of indoor and outdoor space, such as a decent-sized backyard that complements the house’s footprint.

Additionally, the appraiser will factor in the number of bedrooms and bathrooms. A higher bedroom and bathroom count can significantly boost the property’s overall value. Larger homes with more amenities offer more functional living spaces, which is a key consideration in appraisals.

Location

Location plays a crucial role in determining your home’s appraised value. An appraiser will not only evaluate your property but also take into account the broader neighborhood. Is the area well-maintained, and are there positive future developments, such as new schools or growing employment opportunities? If so, this could result in a higher appraisal. On the other hand, neighborhoods facing challenges like high vacancy rates or numerous foreclosures will likely cause a dip in the appraisal value. Additionally, factors such as crime rates and local amenities can further influence the overall assessment, either positively or negatively. This makes it vital to understand the local market dynamics when preparing for an appraisal.

Conclusion

Understanding what can hurt a home appraisal is key to securing the best possible valuation for your property. While factors like market trends and location are out of your control, there are many proactive steps you can take to improve the condition of your home and enhance its appeal. Keeping up with regular maintenance, boosting curb appeal, and ensuring recent improvements are documented can all contribute positively to the final appraisal. When you’re ready to sell, partnering with professionals like Block Appraisals ensures you’re in good hands for an accurate and fair assessment of your home. Prepare effectively, and you’ll be well-positioned for a successful sale.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How can I improve my home’s appraisal value?
You can boost your home’s value by maintaining its condition, enhancing curb appeal, and providing documentation for recent upgrades or improvements. Small repairs and a clean, well-organized home also make a positive impression on appraisers.

2. What factors are beyond my control in a home appraisal?
Factors such as local market trends, location, the size of your home and property, and the age of your house are typically beyond your control. These elements can significantly impact your appraisal value.

3. Does a messy house lower the appraisal value?
Generally, no. Appraisers are focused on the home’s structure and features. While clutter may not affect the value, a messy house can create a negative impression, so it’s still best to tidy up before the appraisal.

4. Will my home improvements increase the appraisal by the amount I spent?
Not necessarily. While improvements like kitchen renovations or new landscaping can increase your home’s value, they often won’t provide a dollar-for-dollar return. It’s important to manage expectations when investing in upgrades.

5. Can I appeal a low appraisal?
Yes, if you believe the appraisal was inaccurate, you can file an appeal. It’s a good idea to present recent comparable sales and additional information that may not have been considered during the initial appraisal.