Schedule a Consultation

Litigation Appraisal In NYC

Book An Appraisal
Law and Legal services concept.

Property Appraisals & Litigation: What You Need To Know

If you’ve found yourself in a legal dispute involving real estate assets, you’re not alone—and you don’t need to panic. Our appraisers in NYC have extensive experience navigating the legal system, and we’re here to support you and your attorney with accurate, defensible property appraisals that provide the foundation for your claims.

As certified property appraisers in NYC, we offer reliable, objective insights into your case from the perspective of expert property evaluators. Whether your dispute involves property damage, breach of contract, partnership dissolution, eminent domain, or any other real estate litigation matter, we provide the professional valuation evidence you need to support your position in negotiations, mediation, arbitration, or court proceedings.

A woman conducting litigation appraisal inside the courtroom

Understanding Litigation Appraisals

Litigation appraisals differ significantly from standard real estate appraisals. When property value is contested in legal proceedings, the appraisal must withstand rigorous scrutiny from opposing experts, attorneys, and potentially judges or juries. These appraisals require heightened attention to methodology, documentation, and defensibility.

Unlike mortgage or estate appraisals where professional standards alone govern the work, litigation appraisals must anticipate challenges, address conflicting expert opinions, and present conclusions in ways that non-appraisers can understand. The appraiser becomes an integral part of your legal team, working closely with attorneys to develop valuation evidence that supports your case strategy.

Common Types of Real Estate Litigation

Breach of Contract

When purchase agreements, development deals, or option contracts are disputed, appraisals establish property values at specific dates to quantify damages or determine proper contract prices.

Partnership & Shareholder Disputes

Business partners or co-owners disagreeing on property value need independent appraisals to support buyouts, dissolution agreements, or establish fair market value for ownership interests.

Condemnation & Eminent Domain

Property owners facing government taking require expert appraisals demonstrating fair market value before the taking, plus damages to any remaining property.

Property Damage Claims

Insurance disputes, construction defects, environmental contamination, or casualty losses require before-and-after valuations to quantify damages and diminution in value.

Bankruptcy & Foreclosure:

Creditors, debtors, and trustees need accurate property valuations for bankruptcy proceedings, workout negotiations, or foreclosure deficiency determinations.

Tax Assessment Appeals:

Challenging property tax assessments requires professional appraisals demonstrating current market value differs from assessed value.

Estate & Trust Litigation:

Disputed estates or trust distributions involving real property require independent valuations to resolve beneficiary conflicts or challenge fiduciary decisions.

How Can A NYC Property Appraiser Help Your Case?

No matter what type of real estate litigation you’re facing—residential, commercial, or investment property—Block Appraisals has a solution for you.

Witness Icon

Expert Analysis & Support

Along with comprehensive written appraisal reports, our expert appraisers are prepared to provide professional support throughout legal proceedings including depositions, mediation, and arbitration. We explain complex valuation concepts in clear, understandable terms for attorneys, mediators, arbitrators, and other parties involved in legal matters.

Our appraisal work is built on sound methodology, thorough research, and defensible analysis designed to withstand scrutiny in legal proceedings. We've prepared appraisals for divorce matters, estate disputes, and various court cases throughout NYC, and we understand how to present technical appraisal evidence in ways that support legal objectives, adding credibility and strength to your claims.

litigation icon

Comprehensive Litigation Guidance

We work collaboratively with your legal team throughout the litigation process, providing guidance on property valuation issues from case strategy through final resolution. Our services include consultation on discovery requirements, assistance with reviewing opposing appraisals, analysis of valuation methodology, and education on appraisal principles for your attorneys.

We help you understand the property's market value through data-driven analysis, identify potential weaknesses in opposing valuations, and develop persuasive evidence supporting your position. From preliminary case evaluation through settlement negotiations or preparation for hearings, we provide the expert support your legal team needs.

Appraiser explaining the validity of commercial appraisal

What Makes a Litigation Appraisal Different

Litigation appraisals require enhanced rigor compared to standard appraisals:

Heightened Documentation: Every conclusion must be supported by detailed documentation anticipating challenges from opposing experts. We provide comprehensive explanations of all adjustments, methodology choices, and data sources.

Multiple Valuation Dates: Litigation often requires valuations as of multiple dates—before damage occurred, at contract date, date of breach, or date of filing. Each date may require separate analysis with historical data research.

Defensible Methodology: We must clearly state all assumptions and demonstrate how they affect value conclusions. Our methodology withstands professional scrutiny and challenge.

USPAP Compliance: All litigation appraisals strictly comply with Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, particularly standards regarding objectivity and disclosure requirements.

Rebuttal Capabilities: We anticipate opposing expert arguments and proactively address potential challenges to our methodology and conclusions within our reports.

Working With Your Legal Team

Successful litigation appraisals require close attorney-appraiser collaboration:

Early Engagement

Engage your appraiser early in litigation. Early involvement allows proper case strategy development, appropriate discovery, and adequate preparation time before deadlines.

Discovery Coordination

We work with your legal team to identify necessary documents, review opposing party production, and respond to discovery requests about our appraisal methodology and data.

Report Requirements

Court rules and scheduling orders specify expert report requirements and deadlines. We ensure our reports meet all procedural requirements and are delivered on time.

Opposing Appraisal Review

When opposing parties present conflicting valuations, we provide critical analysis identifying methodological flaws, data errors, or inappropriate assumptions in their work.

New York at night

NYC-Specific Litigation Considerations

New York City real estate litigation presents unique challenges:

Co-op Valuation Complexities: Co-op appraisals in litigation must address proprietary lease terms, board restrictions, flip taxes, and underlying mortgage obligations affecting marketability and value.

Rent Regulation Issues: Properties with rent-controlled or rent-stabilized units require specialized analysis of regulatory constraints affecting value.

Condo & Co-op Governance: Building assessments, special assessments, reserve requirements, and building-specific litigation impact individual unit values in ways requiring expert analysis.

Zoning & Development Rights: Air rights, transferable development rights, and zoning disputes in NYC’s complex regulatory environment require specialized expertise in highest and best use analysis.

Market Segmentation: NYC’s hyper-local markets mean small geographic differences dramatically affect value. Expert knowledge of neighborhood micro-markets is essential for credible analysis.

The Litigation Appraisal Process

Step 1
Initial Consultation

We meet with you and/or your legal team to understand the dispute, identify valuation issues, determine necessary effective dates, discuss case strategy, and establish appropriate engagement terms.

Step 2
Document Review & Discovery

We review relevant documents including deeds, contracts, leases, prior appraisals, financial statements, and other materials. We identify additional documents needed through discovery.

Step 3
Property Inspection & Research

We inspect the property (where accessible), photograph conditions, research comparable sales and market data for all effective dates, and gather all information necessary to support our valuation conclusions.

Step 4
Appraisal & Report Preparation

We apply appropriate valuation approaches, prepare detailed documentation supporting all conclusions, and produce comprehensive reports meeting court requirements—narrative or form format depending on case needs and procedural rules.

Step 5
Ongoing Legal Support

We remain available as a consultant to work with your attorneys to address questions about the appraisal, review opposing expert reports if needed, provide additional analysis or clarification as the case progresses toward resolution, and support your legal team throughout the litigation process.

What's Included in Your Litigation Appraisal?

Your comprehensive litigation appraisal includes:

Expert Report

Comprehensive written report meeting court requirements, explaining methodology, presenting data and analysis, and supporting value conclusions with detailed documentation.

Property Inspection

Where property is accessible, thorough inspection and photographic documentation. Where access is limited, exterior inspection and alternative research methods.

Market Research

Comprehensive comparable sales research for all effective dates, market analysis, and data supporting all valuation conclusions.

Valuation Analysis

Application of appropriate approaches (Sales Comparison, Income, Cost), detailed explanation of adjustments and assumptions, and reconciliation of value indications.

Litigation Support Services

Consultation with legal counsel, review of opposing appraisals when provided, preparation for discovery, and ongoing availability to address questions throughout the legal process.

Demonstrative Exhibits

Visual aids, maps, photographs, and charts that help explain complex valuation concepts to attorneys, mediators, and other parties.

Supplemental Analysis

Additional analysis addressing issues raised in discovery, opposing expert opinions, or other matters requiring further explanation.

Document Production

Complete file documentation maintained with confidence and transparency for discovery, including work files, research, and all materials considered in forming opinions, ready to be produced if requested during legal proceedings.

Let’s Get Started
Real estate appraisal qualifications document

Our Qualifications

We bring professional credentials and extensive experience to every litigation assignment:

  • Practicing Affiliates with the Appraisal Institute, demonstrating commitment to professional education and standards beyond basic licensing requirements
  • Designated Member of the Columbia Society of Real Estate Appraisers
  • Extensive NYC market experience across all five boroughs and property types
  • Proven litigation support experience preparing appraisals for divorce matters, estate disputes, and court proceedings
  • Collaborative approach working closely with attorneys throughout the legal process
  • Strict USPAP compliance ensuring professional methodology and ethical conduct
  • Ongoing education in appraisal methodology, market trends, and litigation support practices

What Our Clients Say About Us

Block Appraisals
Based on 141 reviews
See all reviews
review us on
AC Mathiot
Scott was very responsive and provided an informative, professional and fair value within an efficient and convenient timeframe. Thank you !
Gabe Leibowitz
Scott's the best appraiser I've worked with. He's incredibly knowledgeable, super thorough and really responsive. I've used him multiple times now on important projects and he's been a dream partner. I can't recommend him highly enough!
Jack Mondello
Scotts’ experience and professional demeanor was evident through the entire appraisal process. His responsiveness and attention to detail made me realize that choosing Block Appraisals was the right decision. I highly recommend them.
Jessica Christo
We had an excellent experience with our appraisal completed by Scott. The report was extremely thorough, detailed, and clearly well-researched. Every aspect of our unit was carefully evaluated and accurately documented. Communication throughout the process was professional, timely, and transparent. We truly appreciated Scott’s attention to detail and would highly recommend him to anyone in need of a reliable and accurate appraisal.
CAVA
After working with multiple appraisers, I can confidently say this experience truly stood out. Scott was extremely professional and meticulous, taking the necessary time to thoroughly research the market and select accurate, truly comparable properties. The final report was detailed, well-supported, and clearly reflected real effort and expertise. It was refreshing to work with someone who approached the appraisal with such care and attention to detail. I highly recommend Scott’s services.
Anthony Esposito
I had a great experience working with Scott for my property appraisal. He was professional, thorough, and incredibly knowledgeable about the local Staten Island market. He took the time to explain his process, answer my questions, and provide clear reasoning behind the valuation. The report was detailed, well-supported, and delivered quickly.

It’s clear he takes pride in his work and cares about accuracy and transparency. I’d definitely recommend Scott and Block Appraisals to anyone looking for a reliable, honest, and straightforward appraiser.

Highly recommended.
doris gardner
I had a fantastic experience with Fred during the appraisal of my home.they were incredibly professional punctual and communicated the entire process
Daniela Sabel
I highly recommend working with Block Appraisals. My husband and I worked directly with Scott and his associate to get a residential building appraised. He is super detail oriented, great with communication and was very patient with all our questions.
Jayron Nesbit
The appraisers evaluated our two-bedroom in Astoria efficiently and professionally. They understood the local market dynamics and recent development in the area. Got the report back in five business days which met our timeline perfectly.
Stephen Daly
Needed an estate appraisal for tax purposes after my father passed. Scott was professional during a difficult time and provided documentation that satisfied the IRS requirements. Their expertise with estate valuations made the process much smoother.
Nikk Simpson
Reliable service from experienced appraisers . Would recommend Block Appraisals
Neil
I contacted scott to get my parents house appraised to sell the property.He advised me to get a date of death appraisal as my parents has passed away.He completed the appraisal on time and kept in touch with me through the process.I would recommend him to anyone who needs his services.
Hungkyu Chun
Scott was very responsive and professional. I like his competence and attitude. I will work with him again and introduced him to my client.
Jenny Magbanua
Scott helped us get two appraisals done with attention to detail and patience as we are new to this experience. Thank you! We highly recommend Scott and his team!
Samina Roy
My mortgage broker recommended Block Appraisals for a private appraisal for a date of death, and they did a solid job. Scheduled quickly, showed up on time, and sent the report back in a timely manner. Would use again.
Show - In - Tube
Had to get an estate appraisal done for my aunt's property in Queens. Scott completed everything within the timeline our lawyer needed, and the valuation was well-documented. Helped us settle things without any complications.
Brian Dotson
Overall great experience with professionals. Solid appraisers and fair pricing.
john waga
It was easier to understand and was able to finish my task in a timely fashion
Sophia Batson
Solid appraisers, fair pricing
Dellquan Roy
Hired them to appraise my small commercial space in Brooklyn. Professional service from start to finish. The appraisers were familiar with the area and the valuation made sense.

Find The Expert Support You Need

Connect with our team today and we will make sure to help you out with your needs. Call us now or send us a message.

Contact us